GUEST LOVE

What guests say after they leave.

★★★★★

Reviews from families, couples and friends who've stayed at Cottage + Bay.

★★★★★

"We’ve stayed at a lot of properties up and down the door peninsula and this place is a gem."

NICK · AIRBNB

★★★★★

"The house was clean, and easy to get into. The location was perfect!"

OUR LAKE VIEUX · AIRBNB

★★★★★

"Every detail was on point and there was clearly a lot of thoughtful intent with the space."

MELISSA · AIRBNB

★★★★★

"Amazing place! Would recommend to anyone with a family or larger group. Morning coffee in the sun room was the best!"

KASEY · VRBO

★★★★★

"This place was perfect for our family NYE getaway...very pet friendly, well equipped for everything we wanted...game room was so much fun...will be staying again!!!"

KATE · VRBO

★★★★★

"Annual girls weekend was elevated by staying at Cottage and Bay."

TRACEY · VRBO

★★★★★

"A wonderful place to stay in Sister Bay. Feels secluded and private, with a beautiful backyard, but is conveniently located."

MARINA · AIRBNB

★★★★★

"The place is wonderful and was a great place to stay. Well stocked and plenty of amenities. The game room was a lot of fun!"

JARED · AIRBNB

★★★★★

"Wonderful experience! Clean, beautiful home, amazing features (game room & dog run), comfortable amenities, and easy communication with the hosts."

HANNAH · VRBO

★★★★★

"Amazing house and property! Plenty of activities for the whole family, and the setup is very well thought out (and pet friendly)!"

GREGORY · AIRBNB

Come see for yourself.

Your Door County stay starts here.

Check Availability · Book Direct

© 2026 COTTAGE + BOUTIQUE · SISTER BAY, WI